ETHICS AND SOCIETY
V83.-0005002
Summer 2000 second session
07/05/2000 to 08/15/2000
Gustavo Ortiz-Millán
gmo9@columbia.edu


Day & Time: M,T,W,R 1:30-3:05pm
Location: 710 Main Building
Office hours: Thursday 3:10-4:00, 503N Main Building

This is an introductory course in moral philosophy. The course is divided into two sections: the first part of the course is devoted to discussions about the nature of morality and the main theories that try to answer the question "how should we live?". The second section (the last three weeks of classes) I want to discuss topics on applied ethics (abortion, euthanasia, death penalty, etc.). This second part is flexible and the topics and readings can be changed according to the interests of the students.

Below is the approximate schedule indicating what material will be covered in each class session. You are expected to have read the assigned reading before the day for which the reading is scheduled.
 
July 
Week 1 
5
Introduction
6 What is morality? Rachels, EMP, chap. 1 
Gilbert Harman, "The Nature of Morality", Ethics 
Suggested: Kurt Baier, "The Point of View of Morality", Ethics
Week 2 
10
Moral relativism Rachels, EMP, chap. 2 
Hugh LaFollette, "The Truth in Ethical Relativism" 
(http://www.etsu-tn.edu/philos/faculty/hugh/relative.htm )
11 Subjectivism in ethics  Rachels, EMP, chap. 3 
Stevenson, "The Emotive Meaning of Ethical Terms", Ethics
12 Does morality depend on religion? Rachels, EMP, chap. 4 
Plato, "Euthyphro", Ethics 
13 Psychological and ethical egoism Rachels, EMP, chaps. 5, 6 
Feinberg, "Psychological egoism", Ethics 
Week 3 
17, 18 
Utilitarianism Rachels, EMP, chaps. 7-8 
Mill, "Utilitarianism", Ethics 
Suggested: Williams, "A critique of utilitarianism", Ethics 
19, 20  Kantian ethics Rachels, EMP, chaps. 9-10 
Kant, "Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of Morals", Ethics 
First paper due 07/24/00 
Week 4 
24
Contractarianism Rachels, EMP, chap. 11 
Hobbes, "Leviathan", Ethics 
25 Rights Feinberg, “The Nature and Value of Rights”, Ethics
26 Virtue ethics Rachels, EMP, chap. 12 
Aristotle, "Nicomachean Ethics", Ethics 
Suggested: MacIntyre, "After Virtue", Ethics 
27 Feminist ethics Rachels, EMP, chap. 12 
Held, "Feminist Transformations of Moral Theory", Ethics 
Week 5 
31, 1
Abortion Thomson, "A Defense of Abortion", Ethics 
Tooley, "Abortion and Infanticide", Ethics 
Sterba, "Abortion, Distant Peoples, and Future Generations", Ethics
August 
2, 3
Euthanasia  Rachels, "Active and Passive Euthanasia", Ethics 
Foot, "Euthanasia", Ethics
Week 6 
7, 8
Death penalty Van den Haag, “In Defense of the Death Penalty”, Ethics 
Nathanson, “An Eye for an Eye: The Morality of Punishing by Death”, Ethics 
Suggested: John Stuart Mill, "Speech In Favor of Capital Punishment" 
"A Broken System: Error Rates in Capital Cases", by James Liebman
9, 10 Business ethics Thomas Donaldson, "Values in Tension: Ethics Away from Home"
Milton  Friedman, "The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase its Profits"
Richard De George, "Corporations and Morality" and "American Capitalism: Moral or Immoral?"
Week 7 
14, 15
Famine and poverty  Singer, "Famine, Affluence and Morality", Ethics 
Arthur, "Famine Relief and the Ideal Moral Code", Ethics
Second paper due 08/15/00 
 

REQUIRED TEXTS

Copies of these books are available at Posman Books, 1 University Place (corner of University Place and Waverly Street).


REQUIREMENTS

Papers. Two papers of 8-10 pages each, double space. The first one is due on July 24, the second one, August 15. No late papers will be accepted. Alternatively, instead of the first paper, you may choose to make a presentation of some 30 minutes in class. The presentation would be about any topic included in this syllabus. You will have to tell me in advance the topic of your paper(s) or presentation.

Regular attendance (no more than three absences). Participation in class (or in any e-mail discussion) is not required, but it may benefit your grade.


WRITING PHILOSOPHY PAPERS

The ethics of writing: write for others as you would have others write for you. I highly recommend that you ask someone else in the class to read over your paper before you turn it in. Not only will this produce a better paper, but the process of explaining your work to others as well as helping others with their work can be a fantastic way to learn. You may also want to take your paper to the writing center (998-8866) where a graduate student tutor can assist you with the writing process. And of course, I am always more than happy to help: come talk to me about your papers before you write them.

For those of you who haven't written philosophy papers before, here you have links to websites that
tell you how to write your first philosophy paper.

You can find more guides for writing philosophy at And, of course, take a look at William Strunk, Jr, "The Elements of Style"


SUGGESTED FURTHER READINGS


Department of Philosophy Web Page

NYU Main page